Sponsored

Deleted User 1813921

Guest
Not finding a need and finding no or diminishing returns for what money is spent is not crusading against those who are into their vehicle as something like a hobby or sport.

In my situation I would not want to compromise the filtering performance or warranty but would definitely consider a modestly priced filter option that could deliver better fuel economy. My pickup was bought as a tool needed for a few years. So far trials with higher octane are not really a return on what is spent. A modestly priced air filter delivering a fuel economy boost would interest me more than spending more at the pump.
Performance modification and usage of higher octane is not about improving fuel economy and saving money its about fun and going faster. Beyond the scope of your intentions with your personal truck. Don’t try and justify your argument because of money saving. The intention is to spend the cash for the thrill. Respect that.
Sponsored

 

bitflogger

Well-known member
Joined
Jul 21, 2024
Threads
5
Messages
139
Reaction score
118
Location
WI
Vehicle(s)
2024 Tacoma TRD Offroad Long Bed
Performance modification and usage of higher octane is not about improving fuel economy and saving money its about fun and going faster. Beyond the scope of your intentions with your personal truck. Don’t try and justify your argument because of money saving. The intention is to spend the cash for the thrill. Respect that.
Nothing says I don't. I'm not alone with the utilitarian interests. This one of two Tacoma related forums is more focused on new stuff and understandable.

The sub-forums here and for sure on another site more about travel, DIY and various build or mod and product things seem to show more like me.

I'm also biased from my light truck alternative being a performance/sport oriented AWD wagon and slightly in the autism spectrum so function always weighs has priority in my brain. The fuel economy and costs are a sincere interest for a lot of us.

I would definitely be after a product that would get a payback over 40,000 to 100,000+ miles, and I'm sure I'll still do occasional tanks of higher octane fuel.

For thrills I'll still be after them but not on public roadways.

:)
 

bitflogger

Well-known member
Joined
Jul 21, 2024
Threads
5
Messages
139
Reaction score
118
Location
WI
Vehicle(s)
2024 Tacoma TRD Offroad Long Bed
Your crusade continues just like I said. If your keeping your truck stock great and you made that clear with your opinion against modifications included. It really seems you guys just wish to argue against any performance mods. Why? Leave us to our own interests and hobby. Should I come argue against some thread of something that interests you with your Tacoma? look at it that way.
I'm not arguing against any thread and don't understand your seeming to be agitated. This air box mod is the sort of thing that interests me but for different reasons than others. Somehow thinking there should not be different styles of pickups even if I don't want them really goes against how I think about choice and markets.

The new powertrain is to me a really nice boost over my V6 with 6 speed Toyotas so it is really simple how I don't need more power. I'd simply enjoy a cost effective fuel economy boost if it is out there. I'll definitely keep my eyes on products like this one.
 

Deleted User 1813921

Guest
I'm not arguing against any thread and don't understand your seeming to be agitated. This air box mod is the sort of thing that interests me but for different reasons than others. Somehow thinking there should not be different styles of pickups even if I don't want them really goes against how I think about choice and markets.

The new powertrain is to me a really nice boost over my V6 with 6 speed Toyotas so it is really simple how I don't need more power. I'd simply enjoy a cost effective fuel economy boost if it is out there. I'll definitely keep my eyes on products like this one.
Bitflogger I understand you. I think maybe you’re confused with these products being strict improvements of performance and not designed for saving money or improving fuel economy. There may be products and tuners that could develop modification for your interest in fuel economy in the future . I respect your personal preference and your entitlement is totally granted. I do not like having to attack and defend but the thread will go south real fast if it turns into a “is it real or fake“ type argument. The moderator has already kept this thread On the rails once from divulging into a big back and forth.
 

32spoke

Well-known member
First Name
Jason
Joined
Aug 7, 2024
Threads
0
Messages
132
Reaction score
84
Location
Petaluma,CA
Vehicle(s)
2024 Tacoma TRD OR
highly doubt if the box will hose anything or that the data logs would show anything, come now what is the pressure drop in the stock setup? Say sub .25 PSI. What is the pressure drop when I drive home from work (sea level to 2800 feet). 14.7 PSI - 13.26 PSI, say 1.5 PSI. Ya think Toyota is datalogging me (I have my tin hat on).
I apologize if I wasn’t clear in my writing. The mass air flow sensor doesn’t measure measure air pressure drop, but the cooling effect air passing through the MAF/electrical resistance which is sent to the Denso Gen 4 ECU along with ambient air temp values to the same ECU, in conjunction with a differential pressure sensor, in the intake manifold-part #89481-WAA01 for the T24A-FTS engine, makes adjustment for air charge pressure/boost and fuel trim. If the rate of air flow in conjunction with air temp is out of value, then it could be recorded and logged. This is no different than estimating density altitude for aircraft, calculated before attempting take off from an airport at altitude with a prop plane. In 2012- VAG/Volkswagon Audi group Bosch MED9x ECU’s did not log power output, on their B8 chassis, but in 2013, with the Siemens “Simos” ECU, they did. Any automotive manufacturer will have some for of data logging for diagnostic events. When leased VAG “Siemens “sinks” ecu equipped vehicles get their oil changed at the dealer, the vehicle is getting plugged in to look for any anomalies, not necessarily for performance mods, but for unnoticed errors the vehicle is detecting. The data is sent directly to Germany to be evaluated.
the pressure drop on air charge is an issue between the inlet side of the intercooler and the outlet side. If engineered properly, a .5-2psi drop in pressure is normal. As air pressure decreases, air volume increases and vice versa. With the three sensors measuring air temp, barometric/intake manifold differential pressure sensor, and the mass air flow sensor-the ecu makes fuel trim adjustments and verifies the results with the upstream wide band oxygen sensor.
 

Sponsored

32spoke

Well-known member
First Name
Jason
Joined
Aug 7, 2024
Threads
0
Messages
132
Reaction score
84
Location
Petaluma,CA
Vehicle(s)
2024 Tacoma TRD OR
A dear friend who's passed away did engineering physics research in a lab funded by 3 auto makers and defense grants. As a hobby interest he build engines for race cars. Now it would be aging work, but he forever spoke of that matter of the sensor and other components as a bottlenecks.

His stories were always interesting to me because his professional and motorsports involvement always had measurement tools and methods.

This product here might be good but my Tacoma is mostly a tool and only personal transportation when my wife wants our car. The stock setup is doing a good job with heavier payloads so cost-effective ways to boost fuel economy would be my biggest interest.
Ahhh! True! A mass air flow sensor is restrictive and for stock engines, a very efficient way to measure air flow. For a performance engine-a speed density setup, when done properly- will create more power… but the risk is it isn’t as accurate/precise as a mass air flow setup.

for mileage-draft big rigs at the peril of stone damage, and coasting a distance before a stop also helps.

since the new Tacoma like to test the fuel and play with spark advance to find the threshold,
In theory: if the spark advance is allowed to be more aggressive, it would create more power with less fuel, less boost. Ideal for partial throttle acceleration. But higher octane fuel costs more.
 

32spoke

Well-known member
First Name
Jason
Joined
Aug 7, 2024
Threads
0
Messages
132
Reaction score
84
Location
Petaluma,CA
Vehicle(s)
2024 Tacoma TRD OR
Bitflogger I understand you. I think maybe you’re confused with these products being strict improvements of performance and not designed for saving money or improving fuel economy. There may be products and tuners that could develop modification for your interest in fuel economy in the future . I respect your personal preference and your entitlement is totally granted. I do not like having to attack and defend but the thread will go south real fast if it turns into a “is it real or fake“ type argument. The moderator has already kept this thread On the rails once from divulging into a big back and forth.
The YouTube video from stillen explains the restriction and how it impacts performance. I am curious how much this box increases noise. I know on naturally aspirated engines, it makes a lot more noise exiting from the throttle body. On my 87 Grand National, When changing the air filter set up, I didn’t notice any noise increase- but the turbo was making lots of noise to begin with.
 

MT-Taco

Well-known member
First Name
Allen
Joined
May 22, 2023
Threads
13
Messages
427
Reaction score
415
Location
Montana
Vehicle(s)
2013 Tundra, 2022 Corolla Hybrid, 2022 RAV4 XSE
Last edited:

32spoke

Well-known member
First Name
Jason
Joined
Aug 7, 2024
Threads
0
Messages
132
Reaction score
84
Location
Petaluma,CA
Vehicle(s)
2024 Tacoma TRD OR
Apparently banks is wrong now also…
https://official.bankspower.com/tech_article/airflow-equals-fuel-economy/

I’m in the market for a better in take. So far it seems Stillen looks to be the most efficient design. I won’t be an early adopter but will be a customer after some of the bugs are worked out? If any?
Any reduction of “resistance” is going to improve efficiency. The biggest gain from a high flow air filter, integrally mounted within an air box to best maximize efficiency is going to improve performance of the induction, but the most gain is when the engine is being flogged, under highest demand, need for higher induction efficiency, compared to cruising in a 25mph school zone. Why wouldn’t K and N filters not show mileage gain? Because the gain may exist, just slight, since most drivers aren’t driving a Tacoma down the Mulsanne @ WOT for 24 hours.
 

Sponsored

Astewart23

Member
First Name
Alex
Joined
Sep 27, 2024
Threads
0
Messages
22
Reaction score
28
Location
California
Vehicle(s)
2024 Tacoma TRD Off-Road
It’s cool that Toyota even offers the TRD parts and a full kit like the Tundra would be cool. There are those that wish to not void warranty and emissions. Is TRD expensive with small gains yes but it keeps you covered by Toyota. Now these aftermarket performance products have huge advantages in performance but most likely void warranty and emissions some do not care about that. I am excited for the aftermarket to catch up to see the guys doing bigger turbo and extensive modifications and create some really crazy Tacoma‘s. Turbo is so cool!
Adding an aftermarket air intake does not void your warranty.
 

dunder

Well-known member
Joined
Aug 19, 2024
Threads
3
Messages
48
Reaction score
65
Location
Pennsylvania
Vehicle(s)
'24 Trailhunter, '25 MB CLE53
I just leave this here: The Trailhunter has 3 less horsepower due to the snorkel. I’m thinking about cutting a hole in the bottom of the airbox. That is my TH ever arrives.
 

theKurt

Well-known member
First Name
Kurtis
Joined
Apr 5, 2024
Threads
10
Messages
61
Reaction score
83
Location
Calgary, Canada
Vehicle(s)
2024 Tacoma Sport+ 6M
When I watched this video, I kept thinking "what about water ingress?". On my last truck, a Land Rover Disco, I was a puddle junkie and it wasn't uncommon for me to get water washing over my hood with "spirited driving" even in rather shallow water like a 6" puddle (wide tires like to push water forwards rather than just to the side).

I doubt I'll have the same spirited attitude with water in my Taco and I won't do any water crossings deeper than say 10" at this point (I'll need to go front to back and identify all the weak points with breathers and connectors and such and mitigate those risks, or let someone on youtube f*ck it up first haha). However, I feel the factory box allows for some splashes to be caught in the lower sections of the intake hoses and not drench the filter outright, like the Stillen box might. Stillen shows their overall design but I don't think they ever mentioned the orientation or position of a filter once installed, though I'm sure they'll do a cone in some way.

Regardless, I think they're focused on "go fast" and not so much the off-road adventure, which is honestly just fine. I'll probably just end up sticking with the factory box and be cautious or maybe a proper snorkel option when they come available and forgo the performance gains.
 
 



Top